Skip to the menu
A cook showers fresh mozzarella over a pie on a wooden peel in the Village Trattoria kitchen

VillageTrattoria

Pizza by the slice, pasta and the Buffalo Pie, made from scratch at 21 South Orange Ave.

Order pickup or delivery (973) 762-2015 Directions
Homemade Italian favorites, made from scratch just like grandma used to do. Quick, friendly, and on the corner of South Orange Ave.
4.4 on Googlefrom 1,085 reviews
40+ piesfrom Grandma to Godfather
7 daysopen from 11 AM
A square slice of Sicilian pizza lifted off the tray with a long cheese pull

Walk the counter

Scroll to turn the ring. Every plate here is from this kitchen.

The Buffalo Pie

Breaded chicken, mozzarella, hot sauce and bleu cheese dressing.

$27

Home of the Buffalo Pie

Close-up of a pie topped with breaded chicken and creamy dressing

Breaded chicken, mozzarella and hot sauce, finished with a drizzle of bleu cheese dressing. The pie the shop puts its name on.

$27Large pie
$17Individual
Order a Buffalo Pie

The specialty board

Seton Hall's late-lunch lineup. Hover a name to see it. Large pie prices shown; individual pies run $11 to $19.

Sicilian squares on a tray with one slice lifted

Call the Sicilian in an hour early

Thick, square and baked to order. Sicilian pies need about an hour, so call ahead or schedule it online.

  • SicilianThe classic square pie
    $25
  • MVP SicilianMarinara, vodka sauce, pesto, fresh mozzarella
    $29
  • Ralphie SicilianUpside-down, fresh mozzarella, roni cups
    $30
Call ahead: (973) 762-2015
A table spread with pies, garlic knots, salads, pasta and a hero sandwich

Feeding the whole table

Pies, trays and garlic knots for the office, the team or the dorm floor. Tell the shop the headcount and they'll build the order.

  • CateringTrays and party orders. Shrimp & garlic tray from $70, a dozen garlic knots $9.
  • Gluten-freeIndividual pie on a rice flour and potato starch crust.
  • KidsA kids menu from $4.
  • Gift cardsSold online for both locations.
Plan a catering order Gift cards

Come by

Open daily from 11 AM

21 South Orange Ave
South Orange, NJ 07079
Get directions (973) 762-2015
  • Monday11 AM – 9 PM
  • Tuesday11 AM – 9 PM
  • Wednesday11 AM – 9 PM
  • Thursday11 AM – 9 PM
  • Friday11 AM – 9:30 PM
  • Saturday11 AM – 9:30 PM
  • Sunday11 AM – 9 PM

Good questions

Is Village Trattoria close to Seton Hall?

Yes. The shop is at 21 South Orange Ave in the center of South Orange Village, a short ride from the Seton Hall campus. It's a long-time slice stop for Pirates.

Can I order online?

Yes, for pickup or delivery at villagetrattoria.com/order-online. You can also call (973) 762-2015.

What are your hours?

Sunday to Thursday 11 AM to 9 PM. Friday and Saturday 11 AM to 9:30 PM.

Do you have gluten-free pizza?

Yes. The individual gluten-free pie is made on a rice flour and potato starch crust.

Why does the Sicilian take an hour?

Sicilian pies, including the MVP and the Ralphie upside-down Sicilian, are baked to order. Allow about an hour, or call ahead.

What is the Buffalo Pie?

The house signature: breaded chicken, mozzarella and hot sauce with bleu cheese dressing. $27 large, $17 individual.

Do you cater parties and offices?

Yes. Trays, pies and garlic knots. Start at villagetrattoria.com/catering or call the shop with your headcount.

Is there another location?

Yes, Village Trattoria also has a Maplewood location. See villagetrattoria.com for details.